
La plupart des compléments vitaminiques ne sont pas bénéfiques pour la santé, selon une étude
Revu par Natalie HealeyDernière mise à jour par Ashwin BhandariLast updated 9 Jul 2019
Respecte les directives éditoriales
- TéléchargerTélécharger
- Partager
- Language
- Discussion
- Version audio
Les compléments vitaminiques montrent peu de preuves de bénéfices pour la santé et certains pourraient en réalité être nocifs, selon de nouvelles recherches.
Video picks for Vitamines et compléments alimentaires
Researchers from the University of West Virginia found that most dietary supplements do not have health benefits, and some could even cause harm.
The team reviewed data from over 270 trials, involving almost one million people. They looked into the effects of 16 different nutritional supplements, along with eight dietary interventions, on mortality and heart health.
Of the nutritional supplements reviewed, the only two that were found to be beneficial were folic acid and omega 3. While healthy eating patterns, such as the Mediterranean diet, or eating low fat, were found to have no effect on heart health. However, a diet low in salt was found to be beneficial for cardiovascular health.
The team also discovered that combining vitamine D tablets with a calcium pill could actually increase the risk of a stroke. But taking calcium or vitamin D alone seemed to have no effect on mortality or heart health whatsoever.
"The reason we conducted this study was that millions of people in the United States and across the world consume supplements or follow certain dietary patterns, but there was no good-quality evidence to suggest that these interventions have any effect on cardiovascular protection," lead author Dr Safi Khan said.
However, he admitted that there were limitations to these results, as most studies relied on participants keeping track of their supplement intake and eating habits through the use of food diaries. Evidence supporting the dangers of combining calcium and vitamin D supplements was not robust.
NHS guidance states that most people without pre-existing medical conditions do not need to take supplements, as a balanced diet should provide adults with all the necessary nutrients to stay healthy. The only exception is vitamin D which should be taken daily from October to May.
Susan Jebb, professor of diet and population health at University of Oxford, said: "This review confirms the vast majority of previous research that has failed to find benefits of most nutritional supplements. But the suggestion that dietary interventions have no benefit does not reflect the totality of the evidence."
Patient picks for Vitamines et compléments alimentaires

Régime et nutrition
Le kombucha peut-il améliorer votre santé ?
Kombucha - once a niche health drink - has become a mainstream staple, thanks to its unique combination of hydration, flavour and fizz. But beyond its distinctive taste, find out if the health benefits of kombucha live up to its reputation.
par Victoria Raw

Régime et nutrition
Magnésium : Bienfaits pour la santé et risques
Magnesium is an essential mineral that plays a role in hundreds of processes in the body. From supporting muscle and nerve function to helping maintain healthy bones, magnesium is vital for overall health. But despite its importance, many people are unsure whether they’re getting enough or whether supplements are necessary. In this article, we explore what magnesium does, the potential health benefits, and when supplementation might be appropriate.
par Josh Alderman
Continuez à lire ci-dessous
Historique de l'article
Les informations sur cette page sont examinées par des cliniciens qualifiés.
9 Jul 2019 | Dernière version

Demandez, partagez, connectez-vous.
Parcourez les discussions, posez des questions et partagez vos expériences sur des centaines de sujets de santé.

Vous ne vous sentez pas bien ?
Évaluez vos symptômes en ligne gratuitement
Inscrivez-vous à la newsletter Patient
Votre dose hebdomadaire de conseils de santé clairs et fiables - rédigés pour vous aider à vous sentir informé, confiant et maître de la situation.
By subscribing you accept our Politique de confidentialité. Vous pouvez vous désabonner à tout moment. Nous ne vendons jamais vos données.